[Reading] ➷ Black Edelweiss Author Johann Voss – Shiningweb.info

Black Edelweiss Black Edelweiss A Memoir Of Combat And Conscience By A Soldier Of The Waffen SS Is A Book By Johann Voss A Pseudonym Detailing The Experiences Of A Soldier In The Waffen SSVoss Served In SS Gebirgsj Ger Regiment Reinhard Heydrich , Part Of The Th SS Mountain Division Nord Written In English, The Book Is Mainly An Account Of His Combat Service Against The Soviets In Northern Karelia And Finland During The Second World War, With A Shorter Section Describing Combat Against American Forces In The Vosges And In The Saar Moselle Triangle In Voss Also Recalls His Experiences Of Being A POW In The United States From , When He Wrote His Memoirs Good story, based on a real life Gives a good view into not only the mind and attitude of a Waffen SS soldier, but the cultural mind of some of the German people of the 1930s and 1940s Interesting views of combat training and combat from the German perspective.Downplays the knowledge and understanding of the treatment of Jews, including the death camps and the Holocaust in general, however Voss seemed to be using the just following orders mantra frequently some interesting dialogue, thoug Good story, based on a real life Gives a good view into not only the mind and attitude of a Waffen SS soldier, but the cultural mind of some of the German people of the 1930s and 1940s Interesting views of combat training and combat from the German perspective.Downplays the knowledge and understanding of the treatment of Jews, including the death camps and the Holocaust in general, however Voss seemed to be using the just following orders mantra frequently some interesting dialogue, though, about the legality of the International Military Tribunal that prosecuted war criminals following the war This book probably speaks for the majority of German fighting men in World War II, January 19, 2010I purchased this book as a source to peek into the mind of a Waffen SS soldier and determine whether his wartime experience supported the ridiculous stereotype handed down on these men over the decade ruthless, evil killers fueled by nothing but pure hate Sure, there is no shortage of evidence to the horrors that numerous members of the Third Reich inflicted upon Europe, but I ve always found it This book probably speaks for the majority of German fighting men in World War II, January 19, 2010I purchased this book as a source to peek into the mind of a Waffen SS soldier and determine whether his wartime experience supported the ridiculous stereotype handed down on these men over the decade ruthless, evil killers fueled by nothing but pure hate Sure, there is no shortage of evidence to the horrors that numerous members of the Third Reich inflicted upon Europe, but I ve always found it naive to assume that those committing such atrocities represented even a majority of the men serving in the German military machine like i don t view those responsible for Abu Graib or the My Lai Massacre representing the entire US Army I must say that I was pleasantly surprised with this memoir and finished it with a belief that Johann Voss, even as a member of the Waffen SS, seemed to be no different than any American soldier in the way he viewed and conducted his military experience doing his job and defending his country, politics aside Almost half of this book focuses on the author s life before joining the military His childhood and home life were not rife with a fanatical devotion to all things Hitler and Nazi ideals, buton the collective strength on each family member s individualism from the Hitler supporting sister to the outspoken anti Hitler uncle If anything, his time prior to joining the military wasabout enjoying his youth, even with his father fighting with the German Army on the Eastern Front His decision to join the Waffen SS was not a political decision, butthat of pride and personal challenge much akin to an American s desire to belong to the Rangers or SEALs Voss duty in the northern sector of the Eastern Front near the end of the war gives the reader a glimpse into a theatre of conflict pretty much ignored The combat he describes is not long and glorious, but short, hectic and blurry Most of his military experience is about coping with deplorable winter conditions than combat He describes his feelings about his former brothers in arms the Finns joining the ranks of the Soviets with understanding even through his unit s arduous retreat through difficult terrain and sub zero weather to escape the Finns The recollection of his final combat experience against Americans are effectively and vividly descriptive the reader can easily visualize the fighting No medals, no glory, no hatred Voss portrays himself as a nothingor less than a citizen soldier Through the course of the book, he introduces us to individuals that have varying degrees of impact on him family members, friends and comrades By the end of the book, most all have been killed As a POW he is faced with the atrocities leveled against the Waffen SS and must shamefully accept it s legacy Nowhere in the book does Voss describe his unit participating in atrocities, but it is left to the reader to determine whether the author s wartime experience was honorable which is what I concluded Since the author wrote his memoirs during his stint as a POW, the book intermittently jumps from his recollection of events to current time as a POW Although that may be an annoyance to some, the breaks to his status as a POW give the reader a sense of intently listening to someone telling a story to the point where you feel like your witnessing the events with the author only to be brought out of the dream like state by the phone ringing very effective Incredibly interesting story, written by a very eloquent and clearly intelligent young solider of the Waffen SS Have read plenty of WW2 solider autobiographies, but always from an US Army officer viewpoint so this was really something different.Black Edelweiss covers Johann Voss real name Paul Karl Schmidt and his life in service, beginning with his formative years growing up under the tyrannical National Socialist regime, and frames his ultimate decision somewhat off piste for him as he wa Incredibly interesting story, written by a very eloquent and clearly intelligent young solider of the Waffen SS Have read plenty of WW2 solider autobiographies, but always from an US Army officer viewpoint so this was really something different.Black Edelweiss covers Johann Voss real name Paul Karl Schmidt and his life in service, beginning with his formative years growing up under the tyrannical National Socialist regime, and frames his ultimate decision somewhat off piste for him as he wasn t a card carrying party member to join and serve not in the regular army, but a combat SS unit.His combat years in the arctic circle on the Finnish front were quite grim, and the endurance of hardships in the winter cold seem constant But as final defeat looms, and Germany crumbled and collapsed around him, his greatest crisis emerges in dealing with firstly the pointlessness of it all, and secondly the discovery of how truly criminal the SS organisation was behind the front lines Here his existential struggle begins as he must reconcile his role as a combat SS soldier, who lost many close friends and sacrificed much for the cause , with a cause which is ultimately branded as evil, despite he and his unit not perpetrating the horrors which the SS is known for In defeat, humilIation is added to unconditional surrender and total defeat Ehre verloren, alles verloren honour lost, all lost Five stars The writing style of the book seems to lack something, much of the combat is glossed over, the author instead seems to spendtime examining the personal struggle of coming to grips with reality of his service and what his organization did during the war Book itself is fairly short, just dont read this expecting any intense descriptions of combat on the Eastern Front or of Operation Nordwind Its no Forgotten Soldier or Blood Red Snow , the writing seems forced and doesnt flow too well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *